Wagner Tubas can clearly be seen with their bells up right in this film with von K conducting the same piece here: http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=1oqasTguizM ...
The entry for Respighi's "Pini di Roma" in Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pini_di_Roma) tells us that "6 Offstage Buccine: 2 Soprano, 2 Tenor, 2 Bass...
Message to All, I am frequently shocked and apalled at the attention and praise given Georg Tintner's set. The only worthwile recording in it is the Symphony...
Yes Kieth I think your right there the W Tubas are much closer to the Buccina - a raw powerful sound - the sound of a Roman Legion on the Apian Way I've been ...
The opinion expressed below is harsh. I agree that the Tintner recordings are in general overrated, but I would hardly call them a "waste of time". The...
wow doug! i am apalled that u diss titner! i can't live without his 4th and 8th! the early versions are sublime!  one of the few sets that gives us fans a...
I am wondering aloud, well I am wondering really loudly since I am writing to this post, why anyone would broadcast his narrowmindedness/closedmindedness to...
Tintner's Second is the 1872 version edited by Carragan, which has the Adagio as the third movement, double crescendos in the codas to the first movement and...
Dear All Surley Rea Doug's opinion is abrupt and forthright which are qualities that others have pinned on me. But why should an opinion be narrowminded or...
John, I think you are missing the point. I don't mind Doug expressing what he likes or dislikes. I am just against the way he put it. The way he uses the...
Dear members (in particular, the ones involved in this discussion), please take a moment, have a deep breath, relax and ... return to the discussion (if you...
Dear All I'm okay for and with moderation. The only fault I can find with forthright expression (which I generally am totally for) as with Doug's is the...
To All, I posted my feelings regarding a Bruckner set. My harsh comments were directed at the interpretation of the Bruckner recordings in this set-as for...
For me, Tintner's set has been the starting point, whereas Celi's Munich set is my culmination of Bruckner experience on CD. In between, I appreciate...
Anton Bruckner (1824-96): a brief introduction to his symphonies Anton Bruckner's eleven symphonies, composed between 1863 and 1896 (the Ninth Symphony's...
Dear friends, sorry, but this paragraph below is absolutely wrong!!!!!! It comes from an old Bruckner article in an old printing of the New Grove and that it...
Friends, After a lot of thought, I chose the recording of the 7th Symphony recorded by Lovro von Matacic with the Slovene Philharmonic Orchestra, released on...
Dear Juan and everyone, That isn't the only "wrong" passage in the article, but it's probably the "wrongest"! "Massive orchestral forces": With the exception...
I'm with Doug on this one. I'm very surprised at Tintner's versions being hailed as some kind of revelation. Here's my personal Tintner experience: when they...
I think the problem with the Tintner set, is that he uses rather mediocre orchestras. Had he a top European orchestra at his disposal the results would have ...
I will break my words and post one more time. Dude, go back to Doug's original post and re-read it. Did he say he was shocked and appalled at the Tintner set...
Dear All So we have all kissed and have agreed that disagreement is healthy (Opposition is eternal delight, as Dick Cheney might have quoted but most...
Hello, in www.hmv.co.jp you can buy a japanese DECCA set with 10 discs conducted by Stein. Includes Bruckner 2 and 6 and the rest is very good, too, ...
You can buy the Stein recordings (on Decca Eloquence) from Nuywell.com in Australia. http://www.buywell.com/cgi-bin/buywellic2/indexb.html ... John F. Berky ...
John, Here is the direct link to the Stein Bruckner 6th http://www.buywell.com/cgi-bin/buywellic2/efly.html?mv_arg=03099 The price is cheap. While you are...
Searching on the site mentioned I could only find of Horst Stein his recording of Franz Schmidt's Buch mit den 7 Siegeln. Does the 10 CD set contain his...
Dear friends: A friend gave me this very interesting URL: The BBC, December 19, 1960 broadcast < http://www.mediafire.com/?wwngnk3wwz2 > It contains a Zip...
Deqar All I've downloaded it but nothing happens except for Real Player saing that new downloads are available for this file and again nothing happens. ...
Dear John & friends, the link is, as it was in my original posting: http://www.mediafire.com/?wwngnk3wwz2 I downloaded a zip file of 142 Megabytes which...
Nope. It doesn't work for me Juan. You still have one chance of my asking Joe Ratzinger to canonize you. John Soutter Rue des Lilas 10 Genève 1202 La...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
