I Like it. I can only be persuaded by my Heart to utter but three movements. They are the ninth as is. That isn't said to incite or to be cute. It is a ...
Jack, everyone is entitled to their own personal opinion around here, at least I hope so. It's when someone starts demanding that other people conform to...
Dear Members of the Anton Bruckner Club, I read an old interview with Carlo Maria Giulini from 1985. Here are some nice quotes from the master: "I never took...
It's certainly a great pleasure to read these quotes. The truly great men and women are also truly modest. Thanks again, Gert, for sharing. Best, Jack...
My pleasure, Jack. Best, Gert ... From: "Jack Kelso" <jkelso@...> To: <antonbrucknerclub@yahoogroups.com> Sent: Friday, July 01, 2005 12:48 PM Subject:...
... Jack, everyone is entitled to their own personal opinion around here, at least I hope so. It's when someone starts demanding that other people conform to...
Dear Warren: As a consequence of your posting , I will stop writing here and unsubscribe this newsgroup. I am not willing to waste my time with sharing my...
Dear Eric: It was proven wrong by musicologists like Paul Hawkshaw and Bo Marschner that the d-minor Symphony was written before the c-minor. The so-called ...
Why and how this demand for "labelling" at all? ... Well, "annulled" and "nullified" have pretty strong negative connotations, at least in this country. After...
Dear Eric: If you like, you may re-check what Bruckner EXACTLY wrote on the score... ... ___________________________________________________________ Gesendet...
Well, curiously, I think exactly the opposite!!! For me, to hear a three movement Ninth is like to hear Beethoven's Seventh without the Finale!!! Yes, I know...
Hi Ben, I won't ask you to reconsider because I don't expect to influence you. I just want to say that I wish you hadn't made the decision to unsubscribe. I...
George, it seems pretty clear to me that Ben quit this Forum the way in which he did because he wants the Forum to blame me for questioning his demands that...
Juan, I have had the same experience listening to the Schubert "Unfinished" in the 4-movement version by Brian Newbould in the Philips recording with Marriner...
Dear George: It is so simple - I don΄t wish my own work to be brought into any connection with the Third Reich, as Warren put it. People who wish to contact...
Warren, I think that the sooner this discussion is closed the better. I don't share your view that Ben wants to patronise the group. He has done quite a lot of...
Hi Warren: I guess your posting is self-revealing. I simply don΄t wish to continue to contribute to a Forum in which members like you are allowed to compare...
wow...what a noise over 0! i kinda dig the idea of a 0 or nullte symphonie! i like the quirkiness of it, but the music overshadows semantics for me! pace und...
Ben, you have no right to dictate what is proper terminology to this Forum. If you don't like comparisons to the pre-1945 mindset, what would YOU call your...
hey guys-ben and warren-lez just dig bruckner and enjoy our relish of die meister-dug __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired...
Doug, it I a rather silly matter, I agree, but it is not a simple matter of proper terminology any longer, it has become a matter of control--whether or not a...
Just to clear the air, I withdraw with apologies my reference to "pre-1945 attitudes" on the part of Ben Cohrs in the hopes that he will in turn grant me the...
Warren, I'm disappointed that you apparently are not content with merely burning bridges but want to mine the roads leading to them and sow the surrounding...
Stephen, I have offered my apology. I would appreciate hearing that I have the right to continue to use what was acceptable terminology in this forum until...
... Yes, Warren, you did apologize, which I've already said and will repeat was an appropriate thing to do. Nobody except you can give you the right to call...
Permit me to say, Stephen, that I am profoundly disappointed that my use of the term "pre-1945" led to the disregarding of my assertion that no one has the...
... This is my last post on this subject. If you said something indirectly or in coded fashion, I don't know why you should get praised for it. A wound from a...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
