... Thankyou John for clearing that up for me. Reading the notes that come with some CDs and with vinyls it was the above I was referring to, hence my reason...
... After all, Bruckner IX for instance has been deformed heavily by Ferdinand Loewe in earlier days, Bruckner V has been deformed heavily aswell by the...
Siggy, I think repeats are an issue pretty much only in the scherzos. Isn't that the case, John? I've learned to take what I read in album/CD liner notes and...
Bruckner Ninth Symphony Finale: resource collection (as on 1.11.2007) Note: Many thanks to Gert van Gelder, Michael Piper as well as other Brucknerians who...
Great!!!!!!!!!!!!!! But you miss the CD of Carragan's "final" version (at least up to now) recorded by Akira Naito and documented in the last issue of the...
Thanks Juan for your feedback. The list only includes the items I presently have in my own collection. Best wishes...martin ... now) ... Bruckner ... to now)...
Dear Siggy, Wether the actions of Loewe or the Schalks were well intended or not doesn't really matter, the point is that Anton Bruckner's music is simply too...
Martin, The UC Berkeley music library has a CD copy of Nicola Samale's recording of an early 1985 draft of the finale as realized by Samale and Mazzuca. (It...
Neil, The Inbal recording of the early Samale/Mazzucca finale is usually easily come by - but the CD label often makes no mention of it. In the incarnation I...
Just to narrow that down a bit - courtesy John Berky's site - the Inbal 9th with Finale is listed there on two occasions, so you might need to be sure you were...
Neil Many thanks for your feedback as well as your offer to check about the quite rare 1985 Samale SM CD copy which I would certainly appreciate a lot in my...
thanx 4 the info ken, i'm gettin inbal's 9th, guten nacht alle! go osu! __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam?...
i'd like to get inbal's 8th, but over 100 bucks?!!!! __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best...
Dear Friends, Recently I had the enormous pleasure of listening to Asahina perform the 8th. In the liner notes of the Skrow performance lies this quote...
Just hope it turns out, on arrival, to be the CD that includes the Finale, Doug! If not - get in touch with me at The Bruckner Journal - brucknerjournal @ ...
Thanks also for the tips on the Inbal, Ken, and, John, for your very clear listings. Doug, my experience with the secondary suppliers for Amazon is that they...
Josh, Max, thanks for your comments, which I passed on to my daughter. She may well join the group! I'll ask her if there were microphones in the hall. Josh,...
... not doesn't really matter, the point is that Anton Bruckner's music is simply too delicate to be changed by others. ... the finest detail how they adore...
But what if Bruckner was agreeing to their re-touchings prior to publication? John ... not doesn't really matter, the point is that Anton Bruckner's music is...
What about Haas putting two versions together into a single version? That certainly isn’t something Bruckner approved of? I think you are trying to come to...
In either Hans-Hubert Schönzler's book on Bruckner or Hans Ferdninand Redlich's book on Bruckner and Mahler (the latter I think), there are a number of...
I don’t want to be a contrarian, but Kna’s performances are classic and have remained in the catalogue for decades.. Remember, Loewe edited the B9 after ...
Yes John, Also let me tell you Hans Knappertsbusch was a great conductor by all means, but I was referring to this idea of creating another kind of a Bruckner...
There you have a very strong point John, but it doesn't stand for 100 per cent. In a lecture given by Georg Tintner, the austrian conductor tells the audience...
Hi Gert, I understand where you are coming from and I agree which much of what you say, but is a complicated issue. Indeed, the Schalks and Loewe definitely ...
The 5th and 9th are special cases among the first published versions, though Deryck Cooke and Robert Simpson never tired of mentioning specific examples of the...
Martin, There was also a series of Bruckner Symphonies released in the 1980s and 1990s with Eliahu Inbal conducting the Frankfurt RSO on Teldec. The Ninth...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
