BJ: I am not really happy with either version that I
uploaded. The full chord version sounds too full. The
sparse version sounds to low and bassy. The original
keyboard version is, of course, and octave higher and
sounds fine. What do others think? Should the sparse
version be transposed to a different key?

BJ: And I am asking again if the version others
have referred to corresponds to either of the versions
I uploaded.

Bob

--- In bachforguitar@yahoogroups.com, "Bob Jaffray." <bobjaffray@...>
wrote:
>
> BJ: I have uploaded two versions of Bach's Minuet in G
> from the Anna Magdalena Notebook adapted for guitar.
>
> BJ: The first is one that seems to have been used in
> Christopher Parkening's Vol. 1 and elsewhere. I imported
> it into PowerTab and saved it _as is_ without editing
> the fret positions.
>
> BJ: The second is a full chord version with arpeggiated
> chords. I created this from an existing rendition to
> add the chords in Anvil Studio, then imported into
> PowerTab, and edited the fret positions downward.
>
> BJ: I am wondering which of these is cloer to the
> version that has been mentioned on the list recently.
>
> Bob
>