Skip to search.

Breaking News Visit Yahoo! News for the latest.

×Close this window

bachforguitar · "Bach for Guitar" email list and downloads

The Yahoo! Groups Product Blog

Check it out!

Group Information

? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Message search is now enhanced, find messages faster. Take it for a spin.

Messages

Advanced
Messages Help
Messages 2 - 31 of 217   Oldest  |  < Older  |  Newer >  |  Newest
Messages: Show Message Summaries Sort by Date ^  
#2 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Wed Jun 30, 2004 2:17 pm
Subject: Bach for Guitar website news
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Hello everybody,

The Bach for Guitar website has changed _a lot_ this week. Renovations included:

         - Netscape compatibility has been restored (by rewriting the entire site
from scratch!!)
         - 356 new free scores added to the "Guitarists Guide". There are now 989
scores (including 472 for guitar).
         - A full listing of Bach's works (the BWV catalog) is incorporated into
the Guide (as grouped "Titles Lists").
         - Anna Magdalena's notebook (though largely spurious) is also catalogued
in the Guide.

Now that these efforts are done, hopefully I'll have more time this summer for
polishing and uploading more of my own transcriptions. I will let you know as
this happens.

Regards,
Alan Melvin
____________________________________________
"Bach for Guitar" website - http://alan.melvin.com

#3 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Wed Jun 30, 2004 2:24 pm
Subject: Noticias del Web site de "Bach for Guitar"
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Saludos a todos,

El Web site de "Bach for Guitar" ha cambiado mucho esta semana. Las
renovaciones incluyen :
         - Se ha restaurado la compatibilidad de Netscape.
         - 356 nuevas partituras gratis han sido agregadas a la
guía "Guitarist's Guide". Ahora hay 989 partituras (incluyendo 472
para la guitarra).
         - Un lista completa de las obras de Bach (el catálogo de BWV)
se ha incorporado en la guía.
         - El "Cuaderno de Ana Magdalena" también esta catalogad en la
guía.

Ahora espero tener más tiempo para concluir muchas de mis propias
transcripciones de Bach y para compartirlas con ustedes. Les
informaré cuando esto suceda.

Recuerdos,
Alan Melvin
____________________________________________
"Bach for Guitar" website - http://alan.melvin.com

#4 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Tue Jul 27, 2004 6:26 pm
Subject: Discussion is now possible (and optional) at "Bach for Guitar" mailing list.
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Dear guitarists,

It is now possible for members to post messages and discuss things at
the Yahoo! Group of "Bach for Guitar". To post a message, write to
bachforguitar@yahoogroups.com .

However, you will not receive these discussions in your email unless
you specifically choose to (by visiting the Yahoo! page and changing
your email settings for the Group). Email preferences for all
existing members are currently set to "Special Notices Only". (I have
done this in respect for those who wish only to get website news, or
to download music from the "Files" and "Photos" pages at the Yahoo!
page.)

Alan
P.S. - These discussions will also be moderated by me, to remove any
spam or posts that don't relate to Bach.
P.P.S. - VERY IMPORTANT - If you wish to write to me in private, use
bachforguitar-owner@yahoogroups.com instead.

#5 From: "Dave Taylor" <thedavidtaylor@...>
Date: Tue Jul 27, 2004 4:03 pm
Subject: 186 members...
thedavidtaylor
Send Email Send Email
 
...and only two messages, both from Alan himself. So I thought I'd
just say Hi Alan and thanks for the website. I play Bach on steel
string guitar, currently working on the Doble from 997. Next I'm
going to have a go at your Presto from 1001. Found another midi
version of it that's a lot faster and in a higher register, but no
tab for it as yet. I'll send it to you if you're interested.
Best, Dave

#6 From: "trewilson" <trewilson@...>
Date: Tue Jul 27, 2004 7:34 pm
Subject: chaconne
trewilson
Send Email Send Email
 
This is a difficult piece for a barely intermediate player like me,
but it helps me to improve my playing of simpler pieces.

#7 From: bwv2041
Date: Tue Aug 3, 2004 12:10 am
Subject: Thanks
bwv2041
 
Downloaded the prelude from BWV1006a the other day. Just thought
some thanks were in order for what appears to be a very polished
transcription.

Gonna lock myself away for three months now, and try and learn to
play it.............

Regards

#8 From: "Luc Vanworkum" <lvanworkum@...>
Date: Wed Aug 11, 2004 2:25 pm
Subject: Many thanks
lvanworkum
Send Email Send Email
 
This is a wonderful website.  Thanks so much for the hard work that
must have gone into this.  As an airline pilot sitting reserve away
from family, this was a most wonderful treasure that will help me
get my chops back.  I look forward to supporting this effort soon.
Thanks again,
LV

#9 From: "katyskomet" <davidyoung5@...>
Date: Sat Feb 19, 2005 3:29 pm
Subject: Bach Lute Suite BWV 996 on Bonell DVD!
katyskomet
Send Email Send Email
 
On the newly released Carlos Bonell DVD,he performs all of the Bach
Lute Suite in Em BWV 996.

This DVD also contains works by Albeniz,Sanz,tarrega,Sor etc in the 1
hour performance.

What makes this DVD unique however is that the viewer can choose to
watch either hand in isolation at any time in the 1 hour performance.

Carlos also gives details of his approach towards interpretation and
technique for each of the pieces.

DVD is available at www.guitarcds.net or from the "guitar school"
section at www.gigajam.com

katys komet

#10 From: "shaktibris" <shaktip@...>
Date: Sun Mar 6, 2005 11:33 am
Subject: Partitas
shaktibris
Send Email Send Email
 
I am curious about the doubles in the violin Partita No1. First of all this
seems to be Bach's
only instance of this (not that I have really studied his works at all). I
wonder if they can be
played over each other, or was it just an extentioon of an idea. If anyone has
seen any
analysis on this I think it would be interesting.

#11 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Sun Mar 6, 2005 6:57 pm
Subject: Re: Partitas
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
You can, at least with a computer. If you want to hear the result, go
to this page on KCN's MIDI site:

http://www.angel.ne.jp/~kcn/?.midi1c

KCN has "made MIDI files of those Double movements playing with the
original movement an octave below." The most convincing are the
faster movements, but all of them make sense this way, like some
maniacal lost keyboard partita.

Alan

--- In bachforguitar@yahoogroups.com, "shaktibris" <shaktip@b...>
wrote:
>
>
> I am curious about the doubles in the violin Partita No1. First of
all this seems to be Bach's
> only instance of this (not that I have really studied his works at
all). I wonder if they can be
> played over each other, or was it just an extentioon of an idea. If
anyone has seen any
> analysis on this I think it would be interesting.

#12 From: "o_chump" <o_chump@...>
Date: Thu Mar 17, 2005 12:15 pm
Subject: A truly thanks to you, very good work
o_chump
Send Email Send Email
 
#13 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Mon Apr 4, 2005 1:09 am
Subject: Bach for Guitar : website news
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Hello guitar people,

I have added to the website a history section, called "What's New".

There you can see what arrangements, scores, MIDIs and whatnot have
been added to the "Alan's Guitarist Guide to Free Bach" each time
over the last couple of years, up through March 31, 2005.

I have also found and added 44 more guitar arrangements (including
solos and ensembles), relinked 141 tablatures (for websites that
moved), and added dozens of other things including MIDIs.

To see details, please go to the website http://alan.melvin.com and
click "What's New".

I hope you enjoy this stuff.

Best wishes,
Alan Melvin
________________________________________
Bach for Guitar - http://alan.melvin.com

#14 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Mon Apr 4, 2005 1:53 am
Subject: Bach para la guitarra / Bach for Guitar : noticias del website
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Hola gente de la guitarra,

He agregado al website una sección sobre actualizaciones,
titulada "What's New". Allí pueden ver que arreglos, partituras,
MIDIs y otras cosas he agregado en la "Alan's Guitarist Guide to Free
Bach" cada vez durante los dos años pasados, hasta el 31 de
Marzo 2005.

También he encontrado y he agregado 44 arreglos más para la guitarra
(incluyendo solos y conjuntos), he restaurado los links de 141
tablaturas (para los websites que se movieron), y agregué docenas de
otras cosas incluyendo MIDIs.

Para ver los detalles, vaya por favor al website
http://alan.melvin.com y haga click en "What's New".

Espero que les gusten estas cosas.

saludos,
Alan Melvin
________________________________________
Bach for Guitar - http://alan.melvin.com

#15 From: "nicolas ferreyra" <acercadelejos@...>
Date: Mon Apr 4, 2005 2:57 pm
Subject: HOla alan!
acercadelejos@...
Send Email Send Email
 
Hola Alan!
Mi nombre es Nicolás y queria decirte que tu pagina de Bach es una de mis
paginas preferidas. Suelo bajame muchas cosas de alli. Quisiera saber de donde
eres. Yo soy argentino, y estudio guitarra clasica hace 6 años en el
conservatorio de lopez bouchard de bs as y siempre estoy buscando gente para
tocar en duo trio o como sea y no se si en tu pagina se podia poner algun
anuncio para expresar esto. En fin, si me podes aydudar en algo con esto te
agradezco mucho y si no no importa, sigo bajando partituras de tu site!.
Un saludo!
Nico.

#16 From: Marc Glickstein <marcglick@...>
Date: Mon Apr 4, 2005 6:15 pm
Subject: Re: Bach for Guitar : website news
marcglick
Send Email Send Email
 
fantastic.  thanks a lot.


--- Alan Melvin <alan@...> wrote:
>
>
> Hello guitar people,
>
> I have added to the website a history section,
> called "What's New".
>
> There you can see what arrangements, scores, MIDIs
> and whatnot have
> been added to the "Alan's Guitarist Guide to Free
> Bach" each time
> over the last couple of years, up through March 31,
> 2005.
>
> I have also found and added 44 more guitar
> arrangements (including
> solos and ensembles), relinked 141 tablatures (for
> websites that
> moved), and added dozens of other things including
> MIDIs.
>
> To see details, please go to the website
> http://alan.melvin.com and
> click "What's New".
>
> I hope you enjoy this stuff.
>
> Best wishes,
> Alan Melvin
> ________________________________________
> Bach for Guitar - http://alan.melvin.com
>
>
>
>
>
>
>

#17 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Tue Apr 5, 2005 3:15 am
Subject: Re: HOla alan!
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Hola Nico / Hello Nico,

Soy estadounidense pero me gusta muchisimo tu pais. Estoy neuvamente
casado con una Argentina hermosa de San Juan. Ella me ayuda con mi
pobre castellano.
/
I'm American but I like your country a lot. I'm newly married to an
Argentine beauty from San Juan province. She helps me with my crappy
Spanish.

Alan


--- In bachforguitar@yahoogroups.com, "nicolas ferreyra"
<acercadelejos@h...> wrote:
>
> Hola Alan!
> Mi nombre es Nicolás y queria decirte que tu pagina de Bach es
una
de mis paginas preferidas. Suelo bajame muchas cosas de alli.
Quisiera saber de donde eres. Yo soy argentino, y estudio guitarra
clasica hace 6 años en el conservatorio de lopez bouchard de bs as
y
siempre estoy buscando gente para tocar en duo trio o como sea y no
se si en tu pagina se podia poner algun anuncio para expresar esto.
En fin, si me podes aydudar en algo con esto te agradezco mucho y si
no no importa, sigo bajando partituras de tu site!.
> Un saludo!
> Nico.

#18 From: "luis_davagnino" <luis_davagnino@...>
Date: Thu Apr 28, 2005 12:29 am
Subject: Te felicito
luis_davagnino
Send Email Send Email
 
El sitio me ha sorprendido muy agradablemente, soy guitarrista
aficionado y verdaderamente las transcripciones me parecen muy buenas y
de mucha ayuda para aprender a interpretar con facilidad las geniales
creaciones de Don Johan Sebastian.
Muchisimas gracias por tu esfuerzo Melvin
Luis

#19 From: "Joseph C. Mastroianni" <jmast@...>
Date: Sun Sep 11, 2005 11:22 pm
Subject: Hello
jcmastroianni
Send Email Send Email
 
Hello fello guitarists and Bach lovers!

#20 From: jmast <jmast@...>
Date: Sun Sep 11, 2005 11:22 pm
Subject: Chaconne-J.S. Bach
jcmastroianni
Send Email Send Email
 
I'm a classical guitarist, for the love of it (non professional) and a Bach lover. This looks like a group that shares my interests!

Joseph
http://www.chaconne.us/index.html

#21 From: Nana Upik <mafia_murtad@...>
Date: Thu Sep 22, 2005 2:28 pm
Subject: Hi,members! Let know me,,
mafia_murtad
Send Email Send Email
 
Heyyo..
I'm Ucrit, 21, a lady classical guitarist.
I'm translating some sheets of preludes into my own variety.
Do you have some preludes??
 
Thanx. a. lot.

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com


#22 From: "Bill Weyman" <bj@...>
Date: Thu Sep 22, 2005 6:43 pm
Subject: Re: Hi,members! Let know me,,
bill_weyman
Send Email Send Email
 
Sorry, Ucrit, I'm just a beginner. And it's HARD WORK!
 
Bill
 
Heyyo..
I'm Ucrit, 21, a lady classical guitarist.
I'm translating some sheets of preludes into my own variety.
Do you have some preludes??
 
Thanx. a. lot.

#23 From: Marc Glickstein <marcglick@...>
Date: Fri Sep 23, 2005 1:08 pm
Subject: Re: Hi,members! Let know me,,
marcglick
Send Email Send Email
 
check out this site...http://www.eythorsson.com/
 
there are multiple scores from bach including some of the lute suites.

Nana Upik <mafia_murtad@...> wrote:
Heyyo..
I'm Ucrit, 21, a lady classical guitarist.
I'm translating some sheets of preludes into my own variety.
Do you have some preludes??
 
Thanx. a. lot.

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com


#24 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Fri Sep 23, 2005 2:13 pm
Subject: Re: Hi,members! Let know me,,
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Ucrit,

You are looking for more Bach to transcribe from, correct? The
easiest way to find sheet music for the original works (and also guitar
versions) is through my site http://alan.melvin.com . There, click the menu to
"Select a category" (keyboard works, violin works, etc.) and click "Go".

At first you will see only lists of guitar versions with links. However, above
each group of guitar versions is a link, "Click for NON-guitar scores". Most of
Bach's works are available for free on the internet (mostly in editions whose
copyrights have expired). Most of these are in PDF form.

Also there are usually MIDI files you can listen to at the click of your mouse.
More importantly, MIDI files can often be used to generate a (rough) guitar
transcription electronically, in any key. It is easiest to begin an arrangement
this way. Many inexpensive programs do this, the best one being TablEdit.

You are most interested in Preludes? You will find the largest quantity of
"Preludes" through the "organ works" page. The sacred organ works BWV 599 to BWV
765 are almost all preludes composed around sacred melodies. Also the "keyboard
works" page will list the most famous preludes like the many "Little preludes"
and those of the
"Well-tempered clavier".

Always check the guitar pages first to see if there are already good
transcriptions of the piece you are interested in.

Please ask also if there's any piece you need help identifying.
Alan





--- In bachforguitar@yahoogroups.com, Nana Upik <mafia_murtad@y...>
wrote:
> Heyyo..
> I'm Ucrit, 21, a lady classical guitarist.
> I'm translating some sheets of preludes into my own variety.
> Do you have some preludes??
>
> Thanx. a. lot.
>
> __________________________________________________
> Do You Yahoo!?
> Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
> http://mail.yahoo.com

#25 From: thirdeyeching@...
Date: Fri Sep 23, 2005 10:27 am
Subject: Re: Re: Hi,members! Let know me,,
talkingtoets
Send Email Send Email
 
Another great spot is Weed's www.classtab.org There's a pretty large assortment of Bach pieces already there. Granted some of them are not transcribed in a very logical fasion. Still, there is a large collection there as well as an extensive list of other composers.

[THE MODERATOR ADDS: Note that all notation on Weed's site is tablature.]

 
Alan Melvin is a great site as well. The last I checked it was still under construction. How's that coming along now. Anyone know?

[THE MODERATOR ADDS: I'll answer this in the next post. By the way, I corrected the spelling (Alan Melvin not Alvin). (Thank God my parents didn't rhyme my name that way. Unfortunately half the world still makes this mistake anyway.)]

In a message dated 9/23/2005 7:18:39 AM Pacific Standard Time, alan@... writes:
Ucrit,

You are looking for more Bach to transcribe from, correct? The
easiest way to find sheet music for the original works (and also guitar versions) is through my site http://alan.melvin.com . There, click the menu to "Select a category" (keyboard works, violin works, etc.) and click "Go".

At first you will see only lists of guitar versions with links. However, above each group of guitar versions is a link, "Click for NON-guitar scores". Most of Bach's works are available for free on the internet (mostly in editions whose copyrights have expired). Most of these are in PDF form.

Also there are usually MIDI files you can listen to at the click of your mouse. More importantly, MIDI files can often be used to generate a (rough) guitar transcription electronically, in any key. It is easiest to begin an arrangement this way. Many inexpensive programs do this, the best one being TablEdit.

You are most interested in Preludes? You will find the largest quantity of "Preludes" through the "organ works" page. The sacred organ works BWV 599 to BWV 765 are almost all preludes composed around sacred melodies. Also the "keyboard works" page will list the most famous preludes like the many "Little preludes" and those of the
"Well-tempered clavier".

Always check the guitar pages first to see if there are already good transcriptions of the piece you are interested in.

Please ask also if there's any piece you need help identifying.
Alan

#26 From: "Alan Melvin" <alan@...>
Date: Fri Sep 23, 2005 5:28 pm
Subject: News of http://alan.melvin.com (Bach for Guitar website)
juncosamelvin
Send Email Send Email
 
Hello everybody,

As you all know by now, I'm a terrible procrastinator. Although I
spend hours each week arranging Bach, and dozens of pieces are
complete, I haven't posted any of them in years because I am constantly revising
and improving. I just can't seem to let go of them.

So, I now resolve to start posting at least two pieces each month
for the next few months, starting in October. I'll do my best to
stick to this through
2005 at least.

As for the rest of my website, it has continued to grow. Speaking of
procrastination, I just realized that I neglected to announce last
month's updates to the site! In August several dozen scores of Bach
were added to the index, and at least 20 guitar arrangements. Also,
some important websites for scores had moved or changed links, such
as the "complete cantatas" site of Tom Zane. These links were also
updated last month. For full details on the update history, see
http://alan.melvin.com/whatsnew.htm

regards,
Alan Melvin
http://alan.melvin.com

#27 From: "Tommie Boy" <Dauphinplayer@...>
Date: Mon Sep 26, 2005 12:21 am
Subject: So how hard do u think playing bach is?
sexypolishman
Send Email Send Email
 
I'm studying for my masters in guitar pedagogy and so i'm trying to
learn an entire bach lute suite for the masters recital(Lute Suite
1006).  So I'm curious about how far along other people are with
playing bach and any stories they have.  Jeez I must have at least
spent a year alone trying to play the prelude.  The first time I heard
the John Williams version I was like (insert scaredy smiley
here)...but now it's not so bad.....as long as I play half as fast as
he does. LOL.  So any stories would be appreciated.

#28 From: Cantemaza <cantemaza_de_miye@...>
Date: Mon Sep 26, 2005 8:59 pm
Subject: Re: So how hard do u think playing bach is?
cantemaza_de...
Send Email Send Email
 
How long have you been playing?  Also, I think it depends on how you learn a piece.  I usually memorize the piece(s) or suite/sonata ASAP then work on the dynamics, color and technique.  By memorizing it, I know the notes and the fingereing, but not the music necassarily, which is where the color, interpretation etc. come in. 
 
There are other ways of course like going measure by measure or phrase by phrase or parts like measures 1-12 first then 13-14 etc.  You need to find what way worls for you becasue not everyone learns the same.  Don't worry about playing it as fast as Williams, besides, he isn't as fast as Parkening on it.  Of course I don't think Parkening did the whole suite.  Can you play through the entire piece from the sheet music?  There is a definite difference between learning a piece and just running through it from the sheet music but it can be very helpful.  Or have you ever hand written the piece, just copied it note per note by hand.  That can be fun and quite educational. 
 
I was recently learning first Cello suite and after running through it for a couple of months on and off,  and without trying to memorize, I can play a large part of it without looking at my book.  The funny part with learning suites, sonatas etc. is when you get the different sections within the movements mixed up.  I always give mysef a good chuckle.  My two cents 
 
Good luck. 
 
neil
(playing since 1988)

Tommie Boy <Dauphinplayer@...> wrote:
I'm studying for my masters in guitar pedagogy and so i'm trying to
learn an entire bach lute suite for the masters recital(Lute Suite
1006).  So I'm curious about how far along other people are with
playing bach and any stories they have.  Jeez I must have at least
spent a year alone trying to play the prelude.  The first time I heard
the John Williams version I was like (insert scaredy smiley
here)...but now it's not so bad.....as long as I play half as fast as
he does. LOL.  So any stories would be appreciated.





Yahoo! for Good
Click here to donate to the Hurricane Katrina relief effort.

#29 From: Philippe Grey <philgreybr@...>
Date: Tue Sep 27, 2005 3:25 am
Subject: RE: So how hard do u think playing bach is?
philgreybr
Send Email Send Email
 
First, I usually do an overview of the piece. Then, I start studying measure by measure until complete an entire audible sequence. The next step is work the "fluency of the play", which I consider the most important part. Speed is consequence. Sometimes I create exercises with some parts of the piece, sometimes I compose a "new" music improvising.
 
I'm not a professional (unfornately), actually I'm a law bachelor and work hard on it. So, I don`t have much time to practice.
Regards to all, Phil.

Tommie Boy <Dauphinplayer@...> a écrit :
I'm studying for my masters in guitar pedagogy and so i'm trying to
learn an entire bach lute suite for the masters recital(Lute Suite
1006).  So I'm curious about how far along other people are with
playing bach and any stories they have.  Jeez I must have at least
spent a year alone trying to play the prelude.  The first time I heard
the John Williams version I was like (insert scaredy smiley
here)...but now it's not so bad.....as long as I play half as fast as
he does. LOL.  So any stories would be appreciated.





Appel audio GRATUIT partout dans le monde avec le nouveau Yahoo! Messenger
Téléchargez le ici !

#30 From: Jon Barchas <free_grooper@...>
Date: Tue Sep 27, 2005 1:28 pm
Subject: Re: So how hard do u think playing bach is?
free_grooper
Send Email Send Email
 
Well, the best I can do is offer my own personal
perspective....

I learned classical violin as a child, gave it up as a
teenager and learned rock guitar, then gave up rock
guitar for classical at 18, learning by sheet and tab,
but mostly tab (once I found Weed's Classical Guitar
Page). I never took lessons, nor did I attempt to
follow any kinda program. After about a year of
learning songs by various composers - Tarrega,
Barrios, Sor, Dowland, Villa-Lobos, Weiss - I almost
exclusively began playing Bach.

Some songs came easy, some didn't - 2-part invention
in Am was a jaunty breeze, as was most of the Lute
Suite in Em, but I never even TRIED BWV 1006. Partly
because I dislike most major compositions, and partly
because well, it looked hard.. as hell. So, I
sympathize if it's taken you a year to get it even
partly done.

I spent many, many, many months trying to perfect the
Chaconne in Dm, on guitar. I could never quite
memorize the Dmaj section though, so I never got it
down pat.

More recently I've been more interested in
transcribing Bach's other non-lute works for guitar,
such as the violin suites and even some of the piano
and organ works. I'm still working on my arrangement
of the Sinfonia in Cm (3-part invention, on guitar,
ouch!) but others, such as that Bach Fugue in Em from
BWV 1003, worked out beautifully. And those songs
required many weeks or months of constant practice
just to get to a decent performance, by no means
Williams, Bream or whatever. (Parkening can suck a big
one.. I don't like his method or his style. But that's
for another day).

Eventually I got tired of the admittedly rather
limited polyphonic options available to one on the
guitar and have been trying to learn the piano for a
year now - exclusively Bach of course, preludes and
fugues from the WTC Bk 1. Now *that* is some hard
s**t. But that's a story for another day...

Jonathan B.

--- Tommie Boy <Dauphinplayer@...> wrote:

> I'm studying for my masters in guitar pedagogy and
> so i'm trying to
> learn an entire bach lute suite for the masters
> recital(Lute Suite
> 1006).  So I'm curious about how far along other
> people are with
> playing bach and any stories they have.  Jeez I must
> have at least
> spent a year alone trying to play the prelude.  The
> first time I heard
> the John Williams version I was like (insert scaredy
> smiley
> here)...but now it's not so bad.....as long as I
> play half as fast as
> he does. LOL.  So any stories would be appreciated.
>
>
>
>
>

#31 From: Cantemaza <cantemaza_de_miye@...>
Date: Tue Sep 27, 2005 2:46 pm
Subject: Re: So how hard do u think playing bach is?
cantemaza_de...
Send Email Send Email
 
Jon,
 
Good one about Parkening.  You gave me a good chuckle.
 
-neil

Jon Barchas <free_grooper@...> wrote:
Well, the best I can do is offer my own personal
perspective....

I learned classical violin as a child, gave it up as a
teenager and learned rock guitar, then gave up rock
guitar for classical at 18, learning by sheet and tab,
but mostly tab (once I found Weed's Classical Guitar
Page). I never took lessons, nor did I attempt to
follow any kinda program. After about a year of
learning songs by various composers - Tarrega,
Barrios, Sor, Dowland, Villa-Lobos, Weiss - I almost
exclusively began playing Bach.

Some songs came easy, some didn't - 2-part invention
in Am was a jaunty breeze, as was most of the Lute
Suite in Em, but I never even TRIED BWV 1006. Partly
because I dislike most major compositions, and partly
because well, it looked hard.. as hell. So, I
sympathize if it's taken you a year to get it even
partly done.

I spent many, many, many months trying to perfect the
Chaconne in Dm, on guitar. I could never quite
memorize the Dmaj section though, so I never got it
down pat.

More recently I've been more interested in
transcribing Bach's other non-lute works for guitar,
such as the violin suites and even some of the piano
and organ works. I'm still working on my arrangement
of the Sinfonia in Cm (3-part invention, on guitar,
ouch!) but others, such as that Bach Fugue in Em from
BWV 1003, worked out beautifully. And those songs
required many weeks or months of constant practice
just to get to a decent performance, by no means
Williams, Bream or whatever. (Parkening can suck a big
one.. I don't like his method or his style. But that's
for another day).

Eventually I got tired of the admittedly rather
limited polyphonic options available to one on the
guitar and have been trying to learn the piano for a
year now - exclusively Bach of course, preludes and
fugues from the WTC Bk 1. Now *that* is some hard
s**t. But that's a story for another day...

Jonathan B.

--- Tommie Boy <Dauphinplayer@...> wrote:

> I'm studying for my masters in guitar pedagogy and
> so i'm trying to
> learn an entire bach lute suite for the masters
> recital(Lute Suite
> 1006).  So I'm curious about how far along other
> people are with
> playing bach and any stories they have.  Jeez I must
> have at least
> spent a year alone trying to play the prelude.  The
> first time I heard
> the John Williams version I was like (insert scaredy
> smiley
> here)...but now it's not so bad.....as long as I
> play half as fast as
> he does. LOL.  So any stories would be appreciated.
>
>
>
>
>





YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS




__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com


Messages 2 - 31 of 217   Oldest  |  < Older  |  Newer >  |  Newest
Add to My Yahoo!      XML What's This?

Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines NEW - Help