At least according to the live recordings I have, to my knowledge
these songs have never been played live (excluding any demos from
prior to 1996 or material recorded prior to their debut album)

THE INNOCENCE MISSION
Mercy

UMBRELLA
Flags
Mintas Waltz
Now In This Hush

GLOW
There

BIRDS OF MY NEIGHBORHOOD
Birdless
Green Grass, Red Tree
She May Turn Around

CHRIST IS MY HOPE
Beautiful Saviour
Christ Is My Hope
Fair Thee Well
It Is Well With My Soul
Morning Star
Sacred Head Surrounded
Were You There

SMALL PLANES
Girl On My Left
I Have Loved You
I Left The Grounds
Rooftop
Some Clear Joy Coming
Song About Traveling
Too Early To Say

BEFRIENDED
Martha Avenue Love Song
Walking Around

1996-2004 DEMOS/RARITIES
A Thousand Miles
Do You See My Brothers
East Virginia
O Little Town Of Bethlehem
Only A Shadow
Peace Be With You
Prayer of St. Francis
The Way You Know