>[Paul wrote] I think the common-practice associations we have with
the tritone, > dominant-to-tonic pull, etc., are very much cultural,
and those in
> other cultures don't necessarily hear these things in the same way.
Well, other cultures' tuning methods and practices are also culturally-
based. I'm open-minded, and seek the exotic, but I'll follow my
roots, and they'll follow their roots.
>There are many layers between acoustic reality and psychomusical
reality, and one of the huge ones is culture.
Which is completely natural, like having a personality. If cultural
and individual egotism is absent, then this inner layer is a plus, and
is an inevitable component of an artist's personality. I really don't
see it as a constraint. Do you? Maybe this is more a matter of
style.
Hello group. I read the statement below, and was wondering if you scholars would be kind enough to say whether it is true, and if so, where I could learn more...
... It depends in what sense you mean "add" and "multiply". It can't be in one and the same sense. ... This seems to be *least* true for phi and *most* true...
... you ... so, ... be ... I see what you mean. I'm mindful of your earlier comments on 'multiplication tones'. I saw the comment in a 'sacred geometry'...
... on... ... What does this mean? What's a 'nest'? Why don't they have one? How are you assuming these chords are tuned? I would have presumed the opposite --...
... the tritone, > dominant-to-tonic pull, etc., are very much cultural, and those in ... Well, other cultures' tuning methods and practices are also...
... be > in one and the same sense. The source on this (it may be new-agey, soft science) is: http://www.soulinvitation.com/heterofi/heterofi.htm Anything to...
Hi again Kelly, I read your reference right through. Well, the first few paragraphs - up to the heading "Applications?" - seems sound enough, if basic, ...
... Most of what's being said here is valid, and applies almost directly to Kraig Grady's work with Mt. Meru scales. He's posted a bit of information on this...
Hi Kelly, I think Paul answered the points on phi pretty much as I would have, so I won't repeat any of that. But I'm intrigued by your synaesthetic experience...
Hi Yahya, ... I've been thinking about this, recalling interviews with true synaesthesics (?), and am not sure.... I don't actually vividly see colors, but...
Hi Kelly, True synaesthesia, as I understand it, consists in perceiving things _as if_ through another sense; there's no question of forcing anything. ...
Yahya wrote <I have only very ... It's interesting you say this, as I've always felt that a 'percussion' section of the orchestra should include instruments...
Kelly, You're actually talking o some fairly subtle sounds - for example, balloons rubbing together - and some that are very difficult to record realistically...