Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
harptalk · HarpTalk - Harmonica Discussion Group
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Message search is now enhanced, find messages faster. Take it for a spin.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
what key would you get?   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #55822 of 56699 |
Re: what key would you get? New Twist . . .

Paul Lee says:
> I cannot recall ever having musicians pay my bills, but audiences have.. and
> they do not care how you get the right note,, as long as it is the right
> note..

Skyak says: Yeah, getting other musicians to pay your bills is like getting cats
to pay for the catfood they are so particularly about, but just never seems to
happen, eh?

I may have said this here before, but the sad truth (for instrumentalists) is
most audiences pretty much have tunnel vision for just the singer, as that is
what the group is usually about. Ask them a few days later and they might not
even be able to tell you if there WAS a harp player in the band. Just the way
it is. Our harp tricks that seem so dandy to us really don't mean much to those
that pay the bills, which Paul rightly points out is that audience. Sometimes we
get lucky, and folks are fans of our instrument, and often its just because they
are amateur harp players themselves and would like take our place up there "if
only for this and if only for that"

So to serve the singer, is our duty then. To mostly comp and chord support, and
occasional get a solo or two to support the tune. All the rest is vanity? as
Shakespeare would say?

Hey the real trick is to be the singer AND harp guy in one. In which case I'd
spend a lot more time on the lyrics than trying to toot an overblow.

Take it easy, Skyak.

PS, Paul has another point. Golden Melodies are Howard Levy's favorites, and
seem to favor overblows. Why are people messing with the marine band mods if
the GM is already designed for it? Just curious






Fri Jul 10, 2009 3:44 pm

skyak52
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #55822 of 56699 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

First I want to say hey to all as I'm new here. I'm a bass player that plays some harp. My band is primarily a country band most of the songs are in G as I...
sirbassalot55
Offline Send Email
Jul 7, 2009
7:24 pm

I myself would get Eb, but that's up to you. ... -- -Just Finished: The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway. -Currently Reading: Nothing, tomorrow going to pick...
Zack
zppoet
Offline Send Email
Jul 7, 2009
9:23 pm

between E and Eb , I would go for the Eb , it enables cross harp in B flat , 3rd position in Fm/ F blues.. and 4th position in Cm /Cblues and 5th position...
Paul Lee
jimboogiebass
Online Now Send Email
Jul 7, 2009
11:01 pm

Eb it is thanks...
sirbassalot55
Offline Send Email
Jul 8, 2009
1:45 pm

... Hey there, Tony, Skyak in. You've got it covered for the vast majority of everything commonly played by typical cover bands. I would find the next most...
skyak52
Offline Send Email
Jul 8, 2009
1:08 am

Just my 2 cents . . . Seems like you have everything covered, band wise. If you needed a specific key for a tune your band currently does, you wouldn't have...
Wayne (Reed) Knazek
thenettrainer
Offline Send Email
Jul 8, 2009
6:21 pm

... If you have a vocalist that always wants it a bit higher or lower than the key it's written in, and the guitarist obliges by just capoing to suit therte is...
pete_handy
Offline Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
1:23 am

... Skyak in. You nailed it, Pete! 6 harps are plenty, but tell that to my key/chord changing amigos, eh? They MAKE me haul around 12 so I can accomodate...
skyak52
Offline Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
2:41 am

Certainly make the Eb your next one. Just don't make it your last one. Many reasons to have them all but for me, a full set is really a complete instrument in...
Gant Eichrodt
gorfalamu
Offline Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
5:47 am

... What Gant said,, !!! look at it this way,, would you truck an old piano with some of those white and black thingies missing to a gig ? money ? sure ,...
Paul Lee
jimboogiebass
Online Now Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
6:34 am

you might also consider that Mickey Raphael sometimes uses a tremelo harp with Willie Nelson for fills and both Mickey and Charlie McCoy frequently use...
Paul Lee
jimboogiebass
Online Now Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
2:14 am

Hi,     Won't a chromatic play in any key?                                               Jack ... From:...
Jack Welch
jjwg03
Offline Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
3:22 pm

... Yes, Pete...
pete_handy
Offline Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
4:02 pm

... sure for melody, and lead solos ,, but not chords in any key,, it will play a lot of "2 note chords" (Diads as opposed to Triads, diads are not chords.. ...
Paul Lee
jimboogiebass
Online Now Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
8:21 pm

Yes, but a chromatic, or even a slide harp just doesn't have the same sound. Also, by using bends, over draws, and over blows a single diatonic can play in all...
walter wood
wwood_38478
Offline Send Email
Jul 9, 2009
5:08 pm

... I got a nice old Koch Chromatic, got everything juicy and functioning, knew enough about music theory to play it in a few key with more sharps and flats,...
skyak52
Offline Send Email
Jul 10, 2009
12:54 am

Skyak, exactly my point, and why I have the full set of 12 diatonics plus the low F and high G, and a few other specialty tuned harps just for certain songs. I...
walter wood
wwood_38478
Offline Send Email
Jul 10, 2009
2:13 am

... Gee, Walter, ya don't want a "What Would Levy Do?" tee shirt? Yeah, I like Diatonics for what do, how they sound, they have limits, and there's good stuff...
skyak52
Offline Send Email
Jul 10, 2009
2:59 am

... aha great minds Do think alike I spent some time trying to overblow,, its all the rage among the Delta Frost players ( odd , as the one thing Delta Frosts...
Paul Lee
jimboogiebass
Online Now Send Email
Jul 10, 2009
6:11 am

... Skyak says: Yeah, getting other musicians to pay your bills is like getting cats to pay for the catfood they are so particularly about, but just never...
skyak52
Offline Send Email
Jul 10, 2009
3:45 pm

What I said!!!!! W Walter Wood United TV Service 501 Poplar St. Pulaski Tn. 38478 ... From: skyak52 <skyak52@...> Subject: [HarpTalk] Re: what key would...
walter wood
wwood_38478
Offline Send Email
Jul 10, 2009
4:16 am

I found that some country tunes are in F sharp and I always keep a B harp around. That's my experience. F sharp is a popular rock key too. Peace Love and...
biscuitboy714@...
Send Email
Jul 8, 2009
2:16 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help