Please read this interview Tell us about the songs. Salaam is one of my most beautiful creations. I started with the word Salaam, keeping Ash in mind; how she...
Karthik, Check out TOI interview with Pritam where he concedes to the copying (in part only) http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/384051.cms Itwofs...
Hi This is a story on IBN Live.com Link: http://www.ibnlive.com/news/twin-trouble-for-woh-lamhe/26100-8.html cheers Dipesh Hindi song with Indonesian lyrics? ...
Hello everyone, I heard on an ad for a local mexican restaurant back i was in school. Its tune was played with the musical instrument Harmonium(kinda) Sounded...
Dear Karthik, For a long time I have a doubt in my mind. Do you have any personal grudge against Nadeem Shravan? Whenever you get a chance you have personally...
Please check the link given below. This will show why people are jealous about Nadeem Shravan's success. http://www.boxofficeindia.com/musicalltime.htm (Link...
I've been a massive NS fan in the 90s. I had got as many as 5 to 6 copies of Aashiqui 'cos I was worried I may lose them. But, the admiration went out of the...
Dear Karthik, Thanks a lot for your kind reply and immediate action. With LOVE, Praphul O. ... amazingly ... have ... subconsciously ... that ... that ... that...
Dear Praful O I read your mail and Karthik's response. I have heard a song in Dari or Pushto (unable to recollect, but I do remember downloading it from an ...
from what i remember 'bahut pyar karte hain' is a lift off the old Mehndi Hasan Ghazal 'Kitna pyara hai mera sanam'. Looking for the source file right now........
Hi, Just to divert a bit from this Nadeem Shravan issue, being an Anu Malik fan i believe if you are going to take off some entries from the totally "non...
South Indian composer Deva copied Nadeem Shravan Aahaa 1997 http://www.musicindiaonline.com/music/tamil/s/movie_name.4115/music_dir ector.79/ Song: Muthal...
I heard Mehndi Hasanji's Gazal. I agree there are some resemblance. But NS has given their input and made this song memorable. Most of NS's copied songs become...
Hello, Karthik, I think you are going very hard on several composers. Your site makes it quite obvious that you are an ARR fan. It looks like you have...
Hard? Unnecessary? These are guys who seek inspiration - blatant or minor and not credit the source. The real life equivalent of that act is stealing from your...
If you do not agree with that Dillagi and Marjawan 'angle', then why did u acknowledge in ur interview with TOI? I donot disagree that the opening lines of...
I also feel that O Priya isn't lifted. The opening is similar, but I don't see any further similarities. Atma's version should be added, better late than...
Just wondering if Rajesh Roshan every got any inspiration from his dad's compositions? Just as Pancham admits to "Baap ka maal" in Kinara (no offence intended...
hai, i think Karthik has done well in giving the interview on times daily, but i wanted to ask him does he know total number of songs N-S has composed?. does ...
Dear Karthik, I read your latest interview. I agree NS copied some songs. But that doesn't make them Indias biggest copy cat. They have given us lots of...
Hi Sunil, That biggest copycat response can NEVER be answered with numbers as a base. It has to be an opinion. And since I was asked this, it was just my...
Dear Karthik, I am not interested in arguments. I agree with some of your opinions. There was a time when nobody was aware about lifting or copying of tunes in...
Let me try one last time. My comments next to yours, below. ... -- Regardless of the situation, if someone asks you and you lie through your conscience, that...
first, i'm not the same Karthik, the host of this site. Praphul, as you are respecting Karthik's opinion (and so is he), I think he has full right to exhibit...
Whoa...finally, one dispassionate visitor! Thank you, namesake. Karthik ... think he has full right to exhibit what he thinks. If everyone refrains from...
I never said Karthik should stop posting copied songs by NS in his website. I appreciate his hard work. But I am totally against his biased statements against...
Although I have been defending Himesh all this while, I will agree with praphul that Karthik has been unfairly been passing comments against Nadeem-Shravan....
