Manohari is a great Saxaphone player & in most RD songs he's played the saxaphone in the second half of RD's career. ... From: Saikat Choudhury...
189
Subramaniam, Vaikunta...
Feb 1, 1999 1:56 pm
Hi all, I needed to bring some of RD's top classical numbers into discussion just to justify he was not a mere 'western-influenced' music director. Apart from...
190
Sai Prasad
SPrasad@...
Feb 1, 1999 2:57 pm
How about: Ghar Aajaa Ghir Aayee (Chote Nawaab, one of RD's earliest films) Bheeni Bheeni Bhor (Dil Padosi Hai) Ayree Pawan (Bemisaal) Hey Sahkhi Raadhike...
191
Jain, Prakash (Prakash)
prjain@...
Feb 1, 1999 3:08 pm
... just to justify he was not a mere 'western-influenced' music director. - Why does it bug people that Pancham may have some western influence in his...
192
Sujay Jalihal
s_jalihal@...
Feb 1, 1999 5:36 pm
hi, my frank opinion is pancham was not at all good at qawwalis. still here are some more.. sholay - chand sa koi chehra - kishore,manna,bupendra,anand kumar ...
193
Jain, Prakash (Prakash)
prjain@...
Feb 1, 1999 5:42 pm
I never found qawwlis entertaining or spellbinding anyway. They all always sound the same. I simply forward/skip over them, or program them out - right up...
194
bghosh@...
Feb 1, 1999 5:49 pm
Hey sujay pancham wasn't good atcomposing qawwalis!! Are you out of your mind?Indian music industry's two most memorable qawallis,based on pure classical ragas...
195
Viswanath Gurram
vgurram@...
Feb 1, 1999 5:52 pm
Thanks Sujay, for the info regarding RDB and Hemant Kumar. By the way, the RDB qawwalis in 'Hum Kisise Kam Nahin' are generally considered to be among his...
196
RAJRRAO@...
Feb 1, 1999 6:34 pm
Hi , I never did like Qawwalis ..But funnily enough the only qawaali's I liked were composed by RD from "hum kisise kum nahin' and 'pari ho ' from zamane ko...
197
Ketan
ketan@...
Feb 1, 1999 10:46 pm
... The last named singer is Anand Bakshi. APparently when the movie was first released, the qawalli was there, and atleast one RMIMer has seen the movie with...
198
Ketan
ketan@...
Feb 1, 1999 10:52 pm
... Seems a bit harsh to call a qawalli on par with this commercial, but hey, I guess it's your choice. ... Plenty, and almost all of them are better ones....
199
Jain, Prakash (Prakash)
prjain@...
Feb 1, 1999 11:07 pm
Ketan, sorry, didn't mean to sound rude. You are right, cannot put a commercial up there with a qawalli. My point was that it's just something I tend to skip;...
200
Sujay Jalihal
s_jalihal@...
Feb 2, 1999 12:09 am
hi bramha, ... ???? what are you talking about ? in MY OPINION the most heard and memorable qawwali is -- na to karvan ki talaash hai - roshan. period. --...
201
bghosh@...
Feb 2, 1999 12:15 am
Hi Sujay I do agree that Na To Karwaan is by far the best of the lot.But these two songs feature among the other bests.You can look-out in HMV's Golden ...
202
Ketan
ketan@...
Feb 2, 1999 1:05 am
... Oh...I did not think u were being rude. No offense taken. I infact found it amusing that qawallis were being compared to Tilda basmati rice. ... True..but...
203
subhash barthwal
subhashc@...
Feb 2, 1999 4:35 am
Excuse me...i guess dicussion is goin' bit negative ,isn't it??? No doubt Roshan Qs are the best in the industry uptodate and even his songs are real gems one...
204
RAJRRAO@...
Feb 2, 1999 4:53 am
exactly my view point subhash!..Its good that u pointed out the fact its a group of RD lovers and I for one can't understand that someone who loves RD'S music...
205
Subramaniam, Vaikunta...
Feb 2, 1999 5:00 am
How many of Roshan's songs do u know to make such a comment ? ... From: RAJRRAO@... [mailto:RAJRRAO@...] Sent: Monday, February 01, 1999 11:50 PM To:...
206
Vinay
vpj@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:20 am
Hi, At last, something interesting going around after all those real audio techno-talk :). We are drawing the conclusion that Pancham could not compose...
207
Saikat CHOUDHURY
SCHOU@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:21 am
Yes!! Hemant Kumar did sing for RD in the film 'Heeralal Pannalal'. The song was picturised on Premnath and goes on like 'Aaja Mere Pyaar Aaaja, Dekh tu aisa...
208
Jain, Prakash (Prakash)
prjain@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:56 am
But surely when we talk of RD we think of excellent combo of different ragas/notations not only that but most of the times its a fusion between indian...
209
Jain, Prakash (Prakash)
prjain@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:56 am
exactly my view point subhash!..Its good that u pointed out the fact its a group of RD lovers and I for one can't understand that someone who loves RD'S music...
210
subhash barthwal
subhashc@...
Feb 2, 1999 6:23 am
Raj! in fact i am so surprised that u took so deceptive point.... all i meant was that two genious who happened to belong to 2 different Era cannot be comapred...
211
subhash barthwal
subhashc@...
Feb 2, 1999 6:27 am
Enjoy.... Hope u will like that.....(All are in excellent sound quality-Stero Mode) can u just let me know the movie name for Ist song....Achi Nahin...
212
Saikat Choudhury
schou@...
Feb 2, 1999 7:48 am
The name of the movie is 'Raakhi aur Hathkadi'. Saikat ... eGroup home: http://www.eGroups.com/list/pancham Free Web-based e-mail groups by eGroups.com...
213
Shubhro Bagchi
shbagchi@...
Feb 2, 1999 12:18 pm
How can one forget the 'Hai agar dushman dushnman' no. from 'Hum Kisise Kum Nahin'. I think this should rank as the best qawwali of all the times. Moreover...
214
Sujay Jalihal
s_jalihal@...
Feb 2, 1999 4:44 pm
hi, it's from rakhi aur hathkadi. picturized on asha parekh and vijay arora (i hate this guy. got good films...) -- sujay ... Mode) ... Sanam....= ... eGroup...
215
Viswanath Gurram
vgurram@...
Feb 2, 1999 4:58 pm
This must sound like an impossible question, but I hope someone has the answer :) I heard a Lata's song for RDB many years ago, and the only thing I remember ...
216
Burleigh Mannath
mannathb@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:22 pm
... Sorry I couldn't reply any earlier, kambakth naukri is keeping me away from more important things in life and this is going to continue on throughout this...
217
Burleigh Mannath
mannathb@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:38 pm
... I thought Bhupendra was a guitarist. Also, it is interesting to note that Bablu was the son of Basu Chakraborti. And then again, is Sapan related to these...
