3rd concerto<br>I couldn't agree with you more about the Argerich recording of the 3rd concerto; I like her Ravel and Chopin but something (besides the ...
920
sarahvence
Nov 4, 2000 1:53 am
so I'm doing this analysis on the format of this piano concerto #2 and am having trouble. could anyone help me out???<br><br><br>sarahvence@... or ...
921
mutterologist
Nov 4, 2000 7:37 am
I haven't heard too many recordings of either of the sonatas. I would like to get one of Ashkenazy playing No.1. I have him playing No.2. Generally he is ...
922
et_the_mighty
Nov 4, 2000 8:03 pm
I've been looking all over the place for the complete piano score of Rach Concerto #3. I tried the Royal Conservatory of Music in Toronto but still can't find...
923
rugby52732
Nov 4, 2000 8:29 pm
as to the piano sonatas, john ogdon did both on an lp for rca in 1968, LSC-3024, which i believe was reissued on cd. i play my lp once or twice a year to avoid...
924
rugby52732
Nov 4, 2000 8:30 pm
see my message 923 here....
925
mike0418
Nov 4, 2000 8:32 pm
please define what you mean by format and I'll try to help....
926
senar1939
Nov 5, 2000 2:32 am
Hi Rugby,<br><br>Yes, yes, I absolutely agree to your opinion about<br>John Ogdon's interpretation of SWR's 1st Piano Sonata! How intensely you paraphrase ...
927
rugby52732
Nov 5, 2000 5:27 pm
thanks for your reply. the slow movement of the first sonata is some of the most compelling,personal, introspective music written by svr. if you wanted to...
928
rugby52732
Nov 5, 2000 6:32 pm
unfortunately, the ogdon sonata cd may be out of print.i find no listing at tower records.com.<br><br>see also my message 908 here....
929
mrieder2000
Nov 6, 2000 4:06 am
Thanks for the Ogdon tip; I hadn't thought of him<br>for this work (silly me!). With regards to the<br>Sonatas, the 1968 recording of the 2nd is available ...
930
rugby52732
Nov 6, 2000 5:34 pm
as for earl wild, he had one of the great techniques ever, and as of my last cd of his 10 years ago was in top shape. the second sonata is a challenge, but...
931
elena_losseva
Nov 6, 2000 8:22 pm
Hi, I am new to this club, and I was just reading some old messages. It seems that there was a question on the extra-musical inspiration of the etudes (raised...
932
senar1939
Nov 7, 2000 1:22 am
Reacting to what I consider as absolute "parlour"-<br>talk regarding Rachmaninoff's 1st piano sonata.<br>I have an impression of total lack of depth with...
933
carefreeeeee
Nov 7, 2000 4:23 am
Pieter,<br>I must disagree to some of the sentiments you showed us. The welcoming message for this club, the first thing I see when I load the page, says "this...
934
mutterologist
Nov 7, 2000 8:23 am
Hello Elena, and welcome! Thank you for your post on the etudes. Yes I was aware of the inspirations that you quoted. But when Saint-Saens orchestrated the ...
935
mutterologist
Nov 7, 2000 8:26 am
Oops! I said Saint-Saens..I meant Respighi, of course! Long day today......
936
rugby52732
Nov 7, 2000 2:41 pm
well said carefreeee. what was 926 here ?<br><br>i respect senars knowledge, and others here, greater than mine, the main reason i participate on this ...
937
mrieder2000
Nov 7, 2000 7:41 pm
First of all, I would like to thank mutterologist and rugby for engaging in the brief but very helpful dialogue regarding recordings of Rachmaninoff's sonatas....
938
senar1939
Nov 8, 2000 1:49 am
Hello Rugby, Carefree(ee) and others interested,<br><br>In the first place I am somehow intimidated, in a<br>positive way, by your lenghty and...
939
senar1939
Nov 8, 2000 2:16 am
Hi Manuel,<br><br>I already typed a lenghty answer to Rugby and<br>Carefree, where I explained I most certainly didn't want to offend you! Your remarks did...
940
mrieder2000
Nov 8, 2000 4:53 am
No problem, Pieter.<br><br>I must admit that some of my earlier remarks about certain recordings, were a bit flippant, especially in light of my "newness" to...
941
mrieder2000
Nov 8, 2000 5:21 am
I'm interested in feedback on the recent "reproductions" of Rachmaninoff's music rolls, based on the originals made in 1919 on an Ampico music roll piano. I ...
942
mrieder2000
Nov 8, 2000 5:26 am
Complete piano score as in 2-piano, or full the orchestral version? You should be able to find the 2-piano score at any decent music store, Toronto has a few....
943
NgsTime
Nov 8, 2000 6:31 pm
Dover Pub. makes a complete score for the rach3, and it also includes the 1st and 2nd. I wish it also had the 4th but it doesn't. It's not large print, but I...
944
et_the_mighty
Nov 10, 2000 5:23 am
So is Dover Pub a publisher? Where can I possibly get it?...
945
NgsTime
Nov 10, 2000 1:31 pm
Dover is the publisher. I've seen it at several large book stores and music stores, you can order it from either place if they don't have it in stock. or you...
946
Rachmaninoff_46
Nov 12, 2000 1:24 am
I have a LOT of thoughts to discuss about these recordings...however, I would first like to know whether you are a pianist or a musicologist?...
947
mrieder2000
Nov 13, 2000 6:59 pm
Although the historical aspects of music intrugue me, I would have to say that I approach this music from the perspective of a pianist. But I am still ...
948
rugby52732
Nov 14, 2000 6:35 pm
would you please explain what you mean by the "unrealistic conditions" under which the recordings were made so to help those of us novices in matters of ...
