Couldn't agree more about the review - it says a lot more about the
reviewer than it does about The Band.

That aside, I know there has been a bit of cynicism about this
collection, at least from the Robbie Robertson angle but I'm still
grateful for the release of any additional material and the discs
contain some real gems.

On first hearing the early version of Jemima Surrender was a real
standout, as was the live version of Smoke Signal (I've always felt
Cahoots never got the recognition it deserved!)

I suppose the downside is that this is a collection for the die-
hards and it is unlikely to kindle a renewed and wider interest in
The Band that they really deserve.

I hope it does well though and that Levon and Garth, as well as Rick
and Richard's families, reap some benefits.

And if anyone on this site has any doubts about whether or not to
buy this, don't hesitate! Get it and crank up the volume.