... first ... copperplate ... Well, I suppose if you want to call end of the 16th century "modern" (Zarlino, Salinas, etc.), then yes, it is a modern...
... Werckmeister III ... records. ... I think that is disingenuous to say it "totally disables" Ibo's assertion that there is no evidence for the application...
Hi dear johnny How are you? I sent a letter to you some weeks ago on 2008/01/24 but ,as I know , you were and are too busy to reply )-; What about barana? If...
... name. ... Just as a matter of protocol in reasoning, I have observed it's awfully easy to confuse or conflate the credibility of several different...
How nice to hear from you Paul. Thanks to you I have read the Story of "A" by Bruce Haynes. Our mutual friend Leslie Ross leant me her copy. Thanks also...
Dear Paul, Could have is the operative here. Ibo, as a musicologist, looks for paper evidence, and you seem to trust his strong assertions. His opinion...
Hello Mohajeri! I hope you and your family are doing well. So sorry, but I never received the letter. The plan is to perform Barana next year when we have...
... [etc] Me thinks it's more a case of personal ax grinding than any real ... You are trying to score some sort of logic point by stating the obvious problem...
"Music: a Mathematical Offering" has impressive range and is pretty hip. It doesn't go too deep in any one subject, and I could do without the lemmas and ...
... Story of "A" ... Do give her my regard! Glad you enjoyed Bruce's book. Thanks ... are mostly ... it apears as though that may be the case. As the I Ching...
Hello Paul, I will pass on your "hello" to Leslie. Now that we are getting closer to being on the same page...I must confess; I have no need for this term,...
... fifths ... this is long ... Not that Sorge's citation of Werckmeister necessarily had anything to do with Bach, of course! That remains to be shown....
Hi Carl, To my knowledge, my paper is the first instance of presenting 34, 41 and 46 tone equal temperaments as possible replacements for the yet current...
Hi Brad, Sorge studied with Bach. An old Grove dictionary paints Sorge as a real sourpuss. But none of this has anything to do with the price of eggs. ...
... confess; I ... the first ... really ... All the time. It really drives me around the bend, for instance, when people use the word "scale" to mean a...
Hi ... I rather suspect that either Brad, or Paul, or both, may be wasting their time on this 'hearing test'. Specifically, the sound that one hears may be...
As I said before, and I thought I said perfectly clearly: I listened to the .aif files after first downloading the whole big zip and then unzipping them....
It would be a mistake to reason that, if something was never talked about *but did not have a name*, then it is all the more likely to have actually happened....
... Yeah, I suspect it was some sort of AGC kicking in. But so what? It only happens near the very end of the sample, after the sound has died away to almost...
... Funny. Must be a Windows thing. Yeah, I hear that they are MP3's, but there isno burbling at the beginning. Problem with Windows is there are so many sound...
... Yes, I missed it. I'm downloading your slides right now to have a closer look. One thing I notice right away, from your explanation that accompanies them,...
Hi Brad: That's what I mean about nothing to do with the price of eggs, etc. Bach and Sorge were "friends" according to Mark Lindley. The old Grove says:...
Hi Tom, How nice to receive your poetic post. Maybe a few reactions. Tom: It would be a mistake to reason that, if something was never talked about *but did...
... Well, Lindley also chided Sorge in print (in the _Oxford Composer Companion: Bach_) for having not ever tried smaller intervals than 1/12 PC in his...
Brad, you ask: "Anyway, don't you think that if Sorge *had* ever formally studied with Bach, he'd probably be the first and loudest person to brag about to...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
