... Okay, now the remaining question is if this temperament is „musically fruitful“ enough to be worth finding a name for. But I’m not sure if I can...
... Exactly. This is what I've been thinking about for some time. IIRC, the first time I used some sort of "mathematical models" for comma pumps in actual...
... I must disagree with this. All music can be performed in strict JI. Just await the Lasso example I'll post later today and I'll think even you will be...
... will be convinced :) Have you heard the comma pump demo which I posted yesterday? If you have, then I wonder what you're still trying to convince us about....
I looked for this, but I didn't see it? Can you post the link? I'd like to hear it. ... I looked for this, but I didn't see it? Can you post the link? I'd...
hi group. I was reading (Grove's article on Harmony) that Zarlino considered string lengths, such that the major triad was 15:12:10, and the minor triad...
... Yes I have. And nothing proves it can't be played in pure JI. Not saying I'm going to attempt the interpretation but you can't say it can't be played in...
... I keep about 1/3 of the files you post in a folder on my hard drive with your name on it, and these two are in it. Can you show your work or explain more...
... Well, it doesn't rank very favorably on the "badness" scale, but that really only measures two properties that are easily quantifiable: complexity and...
... That's a pretty bold claim. If that's true, you should have no trouble with this simple comma pump: http://www.io.com/~hmiller/music/ex/dim12.mid This...
... I consider it the other way around. It's a pretty bold claim to me to say certain music can't be played in JI. I consider JI to be the underlying structure...
... No JI performance would have remotely the same effect. Meanwhile, Marcel, you're so full of it that everybody by now wishes you'd either tone it down or...
Sorry, but the "pure" JI version is certainly the least agreeable of the bunch to my ears. Will these small errors (as I understand them to be) really be...
Some are, some aren't. If you listen to many oboists from (say) the 1930's there is practically no vibrato at all. If you consider that vibrato is sufficient...
... By the way, to avoid my server problems I rewrote the files and put them in 'my' folder http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/tuning/files/sphaerenklang/ ...
... If you downloaded it in May 2008, then it's the one I was speaking about. The overall length should be about 3:57. Well, I don't know if the text of...
Maybe I've lost the plot on this piece and its JI, but out of curiosity I downloaded dim12 and then tried LucyTuning it using 3b2s, which seemed to be the most...
With all due respect what do the playing techniques of 1930 oboists have to do with Renaissance choirs? And 12-TET is the ultimate end product of the solution...
... You're probably only listening for consonance in the chords. There are a few dissonant chords yes, but not dissonant as in out of tune. ... Yes, and it...
Those tunaniks with iphones may find this application interesting. http://leisuresonic.com/cosmovox/ Charles Lucy lucy@... - Promoting global harmony...
... Yep, May 21st. ... Not really, sorry. ... Whoa... I have no idea why you would do any of that! ... Your secret is safe with me, I'm afraid. :( -Carl...
... Hi Kelly I haven't read the articles but this reversal sounds more like a reversal of opinion on what ratios to assign to these triads, nothing to do with...
... [snip] ... You've got to be joking. ... I'll say. ... All the triads in this kind of adaptive JI are tuned perfectly 4:5:6, and as far as I know, were...
... You know I'm not joking. I stand 100% behind this beeing pure JI and this beeing the only way this piece is in tune. ... Yes, and so your view of music is...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
